Review Agenda Item
Meeting Date: 4/24/2019 - 7:00 PM
Category: SCHOOL FACILITIES MANAGEMENT
Type: Action
Subject: 20.17 AWARD of CAPITAL Fund Construction Contract 3 of 4 Bid No. 6354 PLUMBING Work CIP10816 “Boiler System Replacement and Asbestos Abatement” at School 9 to Mengler Mechanical, Inc. for the amount of $350,000.00 for a term of 365 calendar days.
District Goals:
Enclosure
File Attachment:
BOCS PS9 Mengler .xlsx
PS-9 10816 PL LOW BIDDER'S REVISED PROPOSAL & BID.pdf
PS-9 10816 PLUMBING SUMMARY OF BIDS.pdf
Rationale: This resolution is to grant the administration the authority to enter into contract as described above. In compliance with General Municipal Law 103, this contract was let for public and bids were opened in public and read aloud on February 15, 2019. Bids were examined and all due diligence observed in determining the lowest responsive and responsible bidder.

A total of 3 bids were received with the highest bid at $412,027 and average bid of $346,278. The work was designed by Eisenbach & Ruhnke Engineering, P.C. who estimated Contract 3 work be $340,000.

The first low bidder Joe Lombardo Plumbing & Heating of Rockland, Inc. was deemed non-responsive due to a mathematical error in their bid. After interviewing Mengler, the second low bidder and confirming that they understood the scope of work, bids were found to be correct, and the firm had beneficial work history with the district, E&R Engineering, Savin Engineers and this department are recommending award of the subject contract.

Mengler originally submitted a bid of $410,750.00 and after confirming they were the responsive bidder for the HVAC Contract they realized operational efficiencies could be gained and were able to offer a concession for the Plumbing Contract bid, reducing their bid to $350,000.00.

CONTRACT 3 of 4, PLUMBING includes but not limited to performing all plumbing alterations associated with the replacement of the boiler plant, removal of the underground fuel oil storage tank, and gas utility upgrades inside the school. Under the Emergency Declaration for CIP 10815, 10816 & 10851 for Plumbing Gas Conversions the Con-Edison and site gas utility upgrades is being performed by Sun-Dance Energy Contractors.

The overall scope of work for CIP10816 includes four separate construction contracts which include but is not necessarily limited to replacement of the boiler heat plant, unit ventilators, exhaust fans, HVAC controls, natural gas supply line, exterior lighting controls, removal of existing underground fuel oil storage tank, library renovation and any related asbestos abatement work. The estimated cost for this work is $3.1 million and the actual four construction contracts to be recommended for award totals $2.84 million.
Funding: Pending Future BAN Sale
Resolution: Ladies and Gentlemen:

WHEREAS: bids were issued for public advertisement and opened on February 15, 2019 in compliance with General Municipal Law for Bid No. 6354 PLUMBING Work, CONTRACT 3 OF 4 for the “Boiler System Replacement and Asbestos Abatement” at School 9 Project No. 10816, and

WHEREAS: such bids were duly examined and as a result of this examination of the bids submitted, the administration has determined that Mengler Mechanical, Inc., is the lowest responsive and responsible bidder with a bid of $350,000.00.

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: that Bid No. 6354 PLUMBING Work, Contract 3 of 4, for Project No. 10816 “Boiler System Replacement and Asbestos Abatement” at School 9 to Mengler Mechanical, Inc., 1689 Route 22, Brewster, NY 10509 in an amount not to exceed $350,000.00 for a term of 365 calendar days.
Approvals:
Recommended By:
Signed By:
John Carr - Executive Director
Signed By:
Tom Collich - Purchasing Director
Signed By:
Finance Department - Finance Reviewer
Signed By:
Elizabeth Janocha - Deputy Commissioner
Signed By:
John Liszewski - Commissioner
Signed By:
Matthew Gallagher - Corporation Counsel
Signed By:
Dr._Andrea_S. Coddett - Deputy Superintendent
Signed By:
Dr. Edwin M. Quezada - Superintendent of Schools
Vote Results:

Original Motion
Member Kevin Cacace Moved, Member Pasquale Mondesando seconded to approve the Original motion 'Ladies and Gentlemen:

WHEREAS: bids were issued for public advertisement and opened on February 15, 2019 in compliance with General Municipal Law for Bid No. 6354 PLUMBING Work, CONTRACT 3 OF 4 for the “Boiler System Replacement and Asbestos Abatement” at School 9 Project No. 10816, and

WHEREAS: such bids were duly examined and as a result of this examination of the bids submitted, the administration has determined that Mengler Mechanical, Inc., is the lowest responsive and responsible bidder with a bid of $350,000.00.

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: that Bid No. 6354 PLUMBING Work, Contract 3 of 4, for Project No. 10816 “Boiler System Replacement and Asbestos Abatement” at School 9 to Mengler Mechanical, Inc., 1689 Route 22, Brewster, NY 10509 in an amount not to exceed $350,000.00 for a term of 365 calendar days.'. Upon a Roll-Call Vote being taken, the vote was: Aye: 6 Nay: 0 Abstain: 1.
The motion Carried 6 - 0
   
Judith_Ramos Meier     Yes
Rev. Steve Lopez     Yes
Pasquale Mondesando     Yes
Edgar Santana     Abstain
Dr. Rosalba Corrado Del Vecchio     Yes
Kevin Cacace     Yes
Andrea Brown     Yes